|
INTRODUCTION |
Section 2 of 11
|
Urinary incontinence is a medical condition that
has significant negative effect on the quality of life. It causes social stigma,
financial hardship, and associated medical problems. Affected individuals often
delay seeking treatment due to shame and embarrassment. Urinary incontinence is
not a normal part of the aging process. This is a condition that has multiple
etiologic factors.
Urinary incontinence may be divided into 2 broad categories.
- Urge incontinence
- Stress incontinence
Pharmacotherapy is the mainstay of therapy for urge incontinence. Surgery and
physiotherapy are 2 primary treatment options for stress incontinence.
With recent advances in medical technology and better understanding of female
anatomy and physiology, many innovative surgical methods are available for
correction of stress incontinence. This chapter will review these surgical
options.
History of the Procedure: Described by Kelly in 1913, the
anterior vaginal repair is the oldest surgical procedure for correction of
stress incontinence. Kelly believed the cause of stress incontinence was an
incompetent urethra. The anterior vaginal repair was designed to correct this
condition.
In 1949, the Marshall-Marchetti-Kranz (MMK) procedure was described. The
suspension sutures were placed within the urethral wall and tied to the
periosteum of the pubic symphysis. The original MMK procedure was complicated by
urethral obstruction and erosion because the surgical sutures were placed
directly into the urethral wall.
In 1961, Burch reported a modification of the MMK procedure. The
modifications involved placing the surgical sutures at the bladder neck and
tying them to the Cooper's ligament.
The original transvaginal bladder neck suspension was described by Peyrera in
1959. Many modifications of the Peyrera transvaginal bladder neck suspension
exist today. They include Stamey (1975), Raz (1981), and Gittes (1987) bladder
neck suspensions. Although initial success rates were quite promising, the
long-term success rate with transvaginal bladder neck suspensions has been
disappointing.
In contrast, pubovaginal slings are gaining in popularity for all types of
female stress urinary incontinence. Historically, the indication for pubovaginal
sling procedure was limited to women with intrinsic sphincter deficiency.
However, it has been expanded to include Type II stress incontinence.
The current trend is to perform pubovaginal slings or retropubic urethropexy
for correction of urethral hypermobility. The long-term success rate of
pubovaginal sling is reported to be comparable to retropubic urethropexy.
Problem: Stress urinary incontinence is defined as
involuntary loss of urine coincident with increased intra-abdominal pressure in
the absence of uninhibited detrusor contraction.
Type I stress urinary incontinence is defined as urine loss occurring in the
absence of urethral hypermobility. This is the mildest form of SUI. Patients
with Type I SUI have a Valsalva Q-tip angle less than 30 degrees an abdominal
leak point pressure greater than 120 cm H2O.
Type II stress urinary incontinence is defined as stress incontinence due to
urethral hypermobility. Patients with urethral hypermobility have a Valsalva
Q-tip angle greater than 30 degrees and abdominal leak point pressure more than
90 cm H2O.
Type III stress urinary incontinence is defined as stress incontinence due to
intrinsic sphincteric dysfunction (ISD). Patients with ISD have Valsalva Q-tip
angle less than 30 degrees and abdominal leak point pressure less than 60 cm H2O.
Frequency:
- Urinary incontinence affects approximately 13 million people in the U.S,
predominantly women.
- This includes 10-35% of adults and 50% of the 1.5 million residents in
nursing homes.
- Up to 60% of nursing home patients are incontinent, while 30% of elderly
living at home are incontinent.
- Urinary incontinence is an under-diagnosed and under-reported medical
problem.
- An estimated 50-70% of women with urinary incontinence fail to seek
medical evaluation and treatment because of social stigma.
- Only 5% of incontinent individuals in the community and 2% in nursing
homes receive appropriate medical evaluation and treatment.
- Incontinent patients often suffer with this condition for 6-9 years
before seeking medical therapy.
- Stress incontinence affects between 15-60% of women.
- Stress incontinence is a disorder of the young and the old. Over
one-fourth of nulliparous, young college athletes experience stress
incontinence when participating in sports.
Etiology:
- The cause of stress urinary incontinence is complex. Many different
factors contribute.
- They include advancing age, multi-parity, prolonged or difficult labor,
and hysterectomy.
- Other factors that may increase the risk of developing incontinence
include obesity, straining at stool as a child or young adult, heavy manual
labor, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, and smoking.
In cases of stress urinary incontinence secondary to ISD, previous pelvic
surgery, radiation and sympathetic nerve dysfunction are all etiologic factors.
Pathophysiology:
- Two major types of stress incontinence exist.
- Urethral hypermobility
- Intrinsic sphincter deficiency
¡@
- Urethral hypermobility results from weakened anatomic support of the
urethra, whereas intrinsic sphincter deficiency arises from a defect within
the urethra proper.
- When there is loss of anatomic support, the proximal urethra and the
bladder neck descend to rotate away and out of the pelvis at times of
increased intra-abdominal pressure.
- Because the bladder neck and proximal urethra move out of the pelvis,
more pressure is transmitted to the bladder.
- During this process, the posterior wall of the urethra shears off the
anterior urethral wall to cause opening of the bladder neck.
- The uneven pressure transmission and the opening of the bladder neck
results in involuntary urine loss during periods of physical activity,
called Type II stress incontinence.
- Intrinsic sphincter deficiency is a condition in which the urethral
sphincter is unable to coapt and generate enough resting urethral closing
pressure to retain urine in the bladder.
- The anatomic support is normal but the urethra cannot remain closed due
to lack of mucosal seal mechanism.
- Inadequate bladder outlet resistance during times of physical activity
result in involuntary urine loss, called Type III stress incontinence.
Clinical:
- Stress incontinence occurs during periods of increased intra-abdominal
pressure.
- Typically, patients complain of involuntary urine loss during coughing,
laughing, and sneezing.
- Incontinence will worsen during high-impact sports activities such as
golf, tennis, or aerobics.
- In general, women with stress incontinence experience less urine loss
compared to women with overactive bladder.
- Stress incontinence occurs at predictable times.
- Irritative voiding symptoms, such as urinary frequency, urgency, and
nocturia, are typically absent.
- Urethral hypermobility results in smaller amount of urine loss and fewer
pads needed compared to intrinsic sphincteric deficiency.
- Patients with urinary incontinence should undergo a basic evaluation that
includes history, physical examination, measurement of postvoid residual
urine, and urinalysis.
- Additional information from a patient’s voiding diary, Q-tip test, cough
stress test, cystoscopy, and urodynamics may be needed in selected patients.
¡@
- Videourodynamics is the criterion standard in the evaluation of an
incontinent patient.
|
INDICATIONS |
¡@ |
- The type of surgery required depends on the type of stress incontinence
present.
- Individuals often have more than one cause for stress incontinence.
- They may have urethral hypermobility, intrinsic sphincter deficiency, or
a combination of both.
- According to the treatment guidelines released by American Urologic
Association (1997), surgery offers good long-term results as either initial or
second-line treatment. Surgery may be offered as an initial form of treatment
for selected women with stress urinary incontinence.
- Surgery must be individualized for each patient, and it must follow
standard recommendations for appropriate surgery. The option selected depends
on the surgeon’s training and expertise in a vaginal or abdominal approach.
- The most important factor in choosing a surgical procedure is the specific
nature of the patient’s incontinence problem and any co-existing vaginal
pathology. Patient preference, surgical complications, and co-morbid medical
conditions also play a role in the decision-making process.
- The surgical management of stress incontinence can be divided into
procedures designed to restore the active mechanism of continence (artificial
urinary sphincter), the anatomic mechanism of continence (bladder neck
suspension or pubovaginal sling), or the mucosal seal mechanism (pubovaginal
sling, periurethral bulking agent, or artificial urinary sphincter).
- The surgical objective for urethral hypermobility is to improve the
support of the sphincter unit (by preventing the descent of the bladder neck)
without obstruction. The goal of surgery for ISD is to increase urethral
coaptation and resistance.
- Although bladder neck suspension results in both improved support and
compression of the proximal urethra, it does not cure a patient with ISD.
- Pubovaginal sling will correct both urethral hypermobility and intrinsic
sphincter deficiency.
|
RELEVANT ANATOMY AND
CONTRAINDICATIONS |
¡@ |
Relevant
Anatomy: The female urethra is a 4-cm, elongated tube composed of an
inner epithelial lining, a spongy submucosa, a middle smooth muscle layer, and
outer fibroelastic connective tissue. The spongy submucosa contains a rich
vascular plexus that is responsible for providing adequate urethral occlusive
pressure to create the "washer effect," an important female continence
mechanism. Urethral smooth muscle and fibroelastic connective tissues serve to
circumferentially augment the occlusive pressure generated by the submucosa.
All parts of the female urethra are influenced by estrogen. The lack of
estrogen at menopause leads to atrophy and replacement of the submucosa
(vascular plexus) by fibrous tissue. Lack of estrogen is one of the risk factors
for ISD; replacement of estrogen may reverse the effects of ISD. When estrogen
is given to a postmenopausal woman with atrophic vaginitis, the mucosa regains
its turgor with simultaneous up-regulation of alpha receptors and angiogenesis
of the vascular plexus. Previous bladder neck operations, radiation, and
neurogenic disease can also affect the ability to achieve a perfect seal.
- Internal sphincter
¡@
- Women do not have an anatomic internal sphincter like males, but women
have a functional internal sphincter.
- The female internal sphincter is composed of bladder neck and proximal
urethra.
- Under normal circumstances, the pressure of the internal sphincter is
much higher than that in the bladder.
- External sphincter
- The female external sphincter is known as the "rhabdosphincter" and is
composed of 2 types of striated muscle fibers, fast and slow twitch.
- Fast twitch fibers cause sudden stopping of the urinary stream to
provide the voluntary "guarding reflex."
- Slow twitch fibers maintain the constant tone of the external sphincter
to provide involuntary passive continence called the involuntary "guarding
reflex."
- The rhabdosphincter has most prominent effect on the female urethra at
the urogenital triangle. Located about 1.8 cm distal to the bladder neck, it
exerts its influence for a distance of about 1.5 cm of urethral length.
- Pelvic diaphragm
- The pelvic diaphragm lines the floor of the bony pelvis and is comprised
of 4 sheets of muscles, including pubococcygeus, iliococcygeus,
ischiococcygeus, and coccygeus.
- The pelvic diaphragm is often referred to as levator ani. The levator
ani musculature is attached to the inner sides of the bony pelvis by a
condensation of pelvic fascia called the arcus tendineus.
- Levator ani is the most important component of the pelvic diaphragm, and
the integrity of the pelvic floor depends upon its function. When levator
ani is damaged, stress urinary incontinence and/or herniation of pelvic
organs through the vagina may occur.
- Supporting ligaments and fascia
¡@
- The urethropelvic ligament is a fibrous band of connective tissue that
lines the undersurface of the bladder neck and attaches laterally to the
arcus tendineus. It provides the major support to the bladder neck and
proximal urethra. Laxity of the urethropelvic ligament results in stress
urinary incontinence.
- The pubocervical fascia is a fibrous sheet of connective tissue that
lines the base of the urinary bladder and inserts laterally to the arcus
tendineus. Intact pubocervical fascia prevents the herniation of the bladder
and the proximal urethra into the vagina. Damage to the pubocervical fascia
may cause the bladder to herniate through the vagina, resulting in cystocele
formation.
- The cardinal ligaments arise from the arcus tendineus and anchor to the
uterine cervix. The cardinal ligaments stabilize and support the uterus,
vagina, and the bladder. Weakening of the cardinal ligaments may cause
cystocele and uterine descensus.
- The uterosacral ligaments originate from condensation of fibrous
connective tissue overlying the sacral promontory and insert in the uterine
cervix. Uterosacral ligaments stabilize the uterus in the bony pelvis.
Weakening of the uterosacral ligaments may result in prolapsed uterus or
vaginal vault prolapse.
Contraindications:
- Intrinsic sphincter deficiency is a contraindication for bladder neck
suspension of all types (transvaginal, retropubic, and laparoscopic).
Performing bladder neck suspension for intrinsic sphincteric dysfunction will
lead to persistent stress incontinence.
- Performing a bladder neck suspension alone is contraindicated in the
presence of moderate or severe cystocele because urethral obstruction or
worsening of the cystocele may result. In this situation, bladder neck
suspension must be accompanied by a formal cystocele repair at the time of
surgery.
- Presence of atrophic vaginitis and intrinsic sphincter deficiency are
contraindications for in-situ vaginal wall sling.
- Severe urge incontinence is a contraindication for any type of
anti-incontinence surgery. Pre-operative urge symptoms should be controlled
with anti-cholinergic therapy prior to anti-incontinence surgery.
- The absolute contraindications to female artificial urinary sphincter
include uncontrolled detrusor overactivity and high-grade vesicoureteral
reflux. Relative contraindications include the presence of urinary tract
infections and the manual dexterity to manipulate the pump. Patient motivation
is the foremost consideration because there is the possibility of surgical
revision for mechanical problems.
Lab Studies:
¡@
- Urinalysis and urine culture: Urinary tract infection can cause irritative
voiding symptoms and urge incontinence.
- Urine cytology: Carcinoma-in-situ of the urinary bladder can cause
symptoms of urinary frequency and urgency. Irritative voiding symptoms
disproportionate to the overall clinical picture and/or hematuria warrant
urine cytology and cystoscopy.
- Chem 7 profile: Blood urea nitrogen (BUN) and creatinine (Cr) are checked
if compromised renal function is suspected. These tests are helpful for
patients in whom poor renal function, obstructed ureters, or urinary retention
is suggested.
Other Tests:
¡@
- Voiding diary: A voiding diary is a daily record of patient's bladder
activity. It is an objective documentation of patient's voiding pattern,
incontinent episodes, and inciting events associated with urinary
incontinence.
- This is an objective test that documents the urine loss. Intravesical
Methylene Blue test or oral Pyridium or Urised may be used. Methylene Blue
and Urised turns the urine color blue; Pyridium turns the urine color
orange.
¡@
- Patients should resume their usual physical activities while wearing a
Peri-pad. If the pads turn to orange or blue, the patient is experiencing
urine loss. If the pads remain white, it most likely is a normal vaginal
fluid.
- To perform a proper Q-tip test, place the patient in a dorsal lithotomy
position. Make sure the examining table is parallel to the floor. Insert a
sterile well-lubricated Q-tip into the urethra until the cotton swab portion
is completely in the bladder. Then, gently pull back on the Q-tip until the
cotton swab is snug against the bladder neck.
Measure the angle between the Q-tip and the floor with a protractor.
Women with normal pelvic anatomy should have a resting Q-tip angle of 0
degrees with respect to the floor. Ask the patient to Valsalva (strain) and
cough.
An abnormal upward deflection of the Q-tip (greater than 30 degrees) by
Valsalva maneuvers is evidence of urethral hypermobility.
¡@
- The absence of hypermobility suggests that the cause of the stress
incontinence is due to intrinsic sphincter deficiency.
- A critical part of the pelvic examination is direct observation of urine
using the cough stress test or Marshall test.
¡@
- A sterile catheter is inserted into the urethra and the bladder is
filled 200-250 ml with water. The catheter is removed. Observation of
leakage during Valsalva or cough denotes a positive test.
- Standing pelvic examination
- A standing pelvic examination is performed if a pelvic examination fails
to demonstrate urine loss or if a pelvic organ prolapse is suspected.
¡@
- If the cough leak test is initially performed in the lithotomy position
and no leakage is observed, then this test should be repeated in the
standing position. Observable urine leakage in this position constitutes a
positive test.
¡@
- If there is any doubt about the pelvic organ prolapse, the patient
should be examined in the standing position. The patient stands with legs
apart with one foot resting on a step stool. When the patient performs the
Valsalva maneuver, the force of gravity will help the pelvic organ (uterus,
bladder) slide down the vagina to enhance the diagnosis. If pelvic prolapse
is present, the prolapsed organ should be pushed up either with a pessary or
a gauze and the cough stress test should be repeated in the standing
position.
Diagnostic Procedures:
¡@
- The PVR measurement is a part of the basic evaluation for urinary
incontinence. To determine the postvoid residual urine, either a bladder
ultrasound or urethral catheter may be used.
¡@
- If the PVR is high, the bladder may be acontractile or the bladder
outlet may be obstructed. Both of these conditions will cause urinary
retention with overflow incontinence.
- Uroflow is a useful screening test mainly for evaluating bladder outlet
obstruction. Uroflow is volume of urine voided per unit of time.
¡@
- Low uroflow rate may reflect urethral obstruction, a weak detrusor or
combination of both. This test alone cannot distinguish between obstruction
and acontractile detrusor. To properly diagnose bladder outlet obstruction,
perform pressure-flow studies.
- In 40% of patients, stress and urge incontinence coexist. In many
instances stress incontinence may lead to development of urge incontinence.
¡@
- A filling cystometrogram assesses the bladder capacity, compliance, and
the presence of phasic contractions. Most commonly, liquid filling medium is
used. An average adult bladder holds approximately 450-500 ml of urine.
During the test, provocative maneuvers help to unveil bladder instability.
- Abdominal leak point pressure (ALPP)
- An important component of multichannel videourodynamics is the
determination of the abdominal leak point pressures (ALPP). Abdominal leak
point pressures allow stress incontinence (SUI) to be classified into
urethral hypermobility, ISD, or both in combination. It is important to note
that "normal leak point pressure" should approach infinity. In other words,
patients with normal continence mechanism will generate intra-abdominal
pressures (Pabd) high enough to faint but will not provoke stress
incontinence.
¡@
Type I SUI |
ALPP > 120 cm H2O |
Type II SUI |
Urethral hypermobility; ALPP between 90 and 120 cm H2O |
Type II/III SUI |
Urethral hypermobility and intrinsic sphincter deficiency; ALPP
between 60 and 90 cm H2O |
Type III SUI |
Intrinsic sphincter deficiency; ALPP between zero and 60 cm H2O |
The ALPP should be measured when the bladder is half full (eg, 250 mL),
and both the Valsalva and coughing maneuvers should be performed. Initially,
instruct the patient to bear down in gradients (ie, mild, moderate, severe),
and then note the ALPP as the lowest intravesical pressure (Pves) at which
leakage is observed. If Valsalva maneuvers fail to produce the desired
response, instruct the patient to cough in gradients (ie, mild, moderate,
severe) to obtain the ALPP. The lowest intravesical pressure (Pves) at which
leakage is seen is the ALPP. The ALPP obtained with Valsalva maneuver is
more accurate than the cough-induced ALPP. Both techniques should be
employed , however, if Valsalva maneuvers fail to manifest SUI.
Alternatively, both Valsalva and cough-induced ALPP may be repeated by
increasing the bladder volume in 100 mL gradients beyond 250 mL. Increasing
the bladder volume reportedly increases the sensitivity of detecting ALPP.
- Voiding cystometrogram (pressure-flow study)
- A pressure-flow study simultaneously records the voiding detrusor
pressure and the rate of urinary flow. This is the only test able to assess
bladder contractility and the extent of a bladder outlet obstruction.
¡@
- Pressure-flow studies can be combined with voiding cystogram and
videourodynamic study for complicated cases of incontinence.
- A static cystogram (AP and lateral) helps to confirm the presence of
stress incontinence, the degree of urethral motion, and presence of
cystocele. Intrinsic sphincter deficiency will be evident by an open bladder
neck. Presence of a vesicovaginal fistula may also be noted.
¡@
- A voiding cystogram can assess bladder neck and urethral function
(internal and external sphincter) during filling and voiding phases. A
voiding cystogram can identify a urethral diverticulum, urethral
obstruction, and vesicoureteral reflux.
- Electromyography (EMG): EMG helps to ascertain the presence of coordinated
or discoordinated voiding. Failure of urethral relaxation during bladder
contraction results in discoordinated voiding (detrusor sphincter dyssynergia).
- The precise role of cystoscopy in the evaluation of female urinary
incontinence is controversial. Less than 2% of bladder tumors have been
identified by routinely performing cystoscopy in incontinent women.
¡@
- However, cystoscopy allows discovery of bladder lesions, such as stitch
in the bladder, bladder cancer, and bladder stone, which would remain
undiagnosed by urodynamics alone. A visual inspection of the urethra helps
to establish the presence of urethral stricture or gross evidence of poor
urethral closure.
¡@
- There is general agreement that cystoscopy is indicated for patients
complaining of persistent irritative voiding symptoms or hematuria. Obvious
causes of bladder overactivity such as cystitis, stone, and tumor can be
easily diagnosed. This information is important in determining the etiology
of the incontinence and may influence treatment decisions.
¡@
- This author also performs urethroscopy to assess the structure and
function of the urethral sphincter mechanism.
- Dynamic retrograde urethroscopy
- The cystoscope is introduced into the bladder. The bladder is filled to
250 ml with irrigant. The flow of the irrigant is turned off. The cystoscope
is withdrawn to midurethra. The activity of the urethral sphincter mechanism
is observed at rest and with Valsalva maneuvers.
¡@
- Patients with Type II incontinence have a closed bladder neck at rest
and have an intact voluntary guarding reflex. Patients with Type III
incontinence have an open bladder neck at rest and have an impaired
voluntary guarding reflex.
- Videourodynamics is the gold standard for evaluation of an incontinent
patient. Videourodynamics combines the radiographic findings of VCUG and
multichannel urodynamics. Videourodynamics is the most sophisticated
diagnostic test for an incontinent patient.
Performing urodynamics:
Instruct the patient to arrive at the urodynamic laboratory with a full
bladder. Perform a noninvasive uroflow and PVR. Place the patient in the
dorsolithotomy position. Prepare her genitalia, and drape using sterile
technique.
Perform flexible cystoscopy. Survey the entire bladder urothelium and
then retroflex the cystoscope to examine the bladder neck. Fill the bladder
to 250 mL of water (see below).
Next, perform the CST and Q-tip test as described previously. Perform a
detailed speculum examination with one half of the gynecology speculum
pointing at the anterior, posterior, and vaginal apex for a view of pelvic
organ prolapse. During the pelvic examination, assess the functional
integrity of the pelvic floor muscles by examining the perineal body and
checking the rectal tone. The presence of levator ani muscle dysfunction or
tenderness may be elicited by gentle palpation of the levator ani
musculature in the paravaginal fornices.
Perform a standing CST and/or pelvic examination as needed (see above).
Drain the bladder. Place a urodynamic urethral catheter (ie, 7 Fr. Cook
dual-lumen pigtailed catheter), rectal tube, and EMG electrodes.
Rotate the patient to a sitting position and equalize transducers.
Commence bladder filling using room temperature contrast (Conray). Cold
water may evoke false positive detrusor contractions (phasic contractions).
Fill the bladder at medium rate (eg, 60 mL/min). Assess the first sensation
of filling fullness, and assess urge are assessed Note bladder compliance
and mark the presence of uninhibited detrusor contractions are marked.
When the bladder fills to 250 mL, measure the ALPP. Instruct the patient
to perform the Valsalva in gradients (ie, mild, moderate, severe) followed
by cough (ie, mild, moderate, severe). Observe the urine leakage
fluoroscopically and by direct inspection. At this point, note the activity
of the bladder neck, urethral mobility, and the presence of cystocele using
fluoroscopy (static cystogram).
Upon completion of ALPP, finish the filling CMG to completion. When the
patient has a strong desire to void, perform a voiding CMG (pressure-flow).
At this point, note urodynamic parameters,, such as maximal flow rate (Qmax)
and detrusor pressure at maximal flow rate (PdetQmax).
During the voiding CMG, note the activity of the EMG electrodes and
voiding cystogram (VCUG) are noted for possible detrusor sphincter
dyssynergia (DSD). Confirm the presence of DSD is confirmed by increases in
EMG activity during detrusor contraction or closure of the external
sphincter on VCUG during voiding.
After the patient voids to completion, the video-urodynamic study is
complete. The patient is informed on the findings on urodynamic studies and
is sent home on with an oral antibiotic.
|
TREATMENT |
¡@ |
Surgical therapy:
Operations for urethral hypermobility
Surgical procedures for urethral hypermobility reposition the bladder neck
into a normal anatomic position at rest and during physical exertion. When the
bladder neck is in the correct anatomic position, it stays closed during periods
of increased abdominal pressure. The 3 main types of procedures used for
correction of urethral hypermobility are retropubic bladder neck suspension,
transvaginal suspension, and pubovaginal sling.
Retropubic or transvaginal needle suspension is recommended over anterior
vaginal repair for hypermobility. Retropubic and transvaginal suspension
procedures are superior to anterior repair in “curing?stress incontinence.
For hypermobility with coexisting ISD, the surgical procedure should
stabilize the anatomic support and compress the urethra, which means using one
of the sling procedures. Pubovaginal slings produce better long-term outcomes
than transvaginal bladder neck suspensions for correction of urethral
hypermobility.
¡@
- Retropubic urethropexy
- Retropubic suspension procedures have a long-term (greater than 4 years)
success rate of about 84% in curing stress incontinence caused by urethral
hypermobility. The Agency for Health Care Policy and Research (AHCPR)
reviewed 45 studies incorporating 3,882 patients who underwent retropubic
urethropexy. Long-term cure rates averaged 79%, and 84% were cured or
improved with retropubic surgery.
¡@
- According to the AHCPR, overall complication rates reported for
retropubic operations averaged 18% (range 6%-57%); the incidence of wound
infections, urinary retention, de novo detrusor instability, and dyspareunia
were in the 3-15% range. Postoperative enterocele and rectocele was most
prominent after Burch urethropexy, occurring in up to 12% of patients.
¡@
- Transvaginal urethropexy
¡@
- The transvaginal bladder neck suspension is often chosen when the
surgeon has to repair pelvic organ prolapse at the time of correcting
urethral hypermobility.
¡@
- Of the 3,015 patients studied in the research reviewed by AHCPR, most
had the Stamey procedure and the others had the Pereyra-Raz procedure. For
the combined series, 74% were continent postoperatively and 84% were cured
or improved. Based on retrospective chart reviews, the overall long-term
cure rate has been reported to be about 67% for transvaginal bladder neck
suspensions. However, outcomes data report that bladder neck suspensions
have higher failure rates than previously reported by retrospective chart
reviews. The reported cure rates at 1 year, 2 year, and 3 year follow-ups
were 78%, 47%, and 20%, respectively. Based on the outcomes analysis, the
mean time to failure appears to be approximately 50% after two years. With
longer follow-up, the apparent cure rate with transvaginal bladder neck
suspension appears to decrease precipitously.
¡@
- Infectious complications included UTI, suture abscess, wound infection,
vaginal granuloma, and sepsis. Obstructive complications included urinary
retention (longer than 3-week duration), urethral obstruction, and
obstructive voiding symptoms. Vesicocutaneous fistula, pelvic hematoma, new
onset of symptomatic urge incontinence, prolonged suprapubic pain, and de
novo pelvic floor defects were additional complications.
¡@
- Transvaginal bladder neck suspension depends on the strength of the
periurethral tissues on either side of the bladder neck. A common cause of
delayed failure is sutures pulling through the periurethral tissue.
¡@
- The patient with a poorly supported bladder neck with no suspicion of
ISD is commonly treated with transvaginal bladder neck suspension; however,
the long-term success rate with transvaginal bladder neck suspension has
been quite disappointing. The current trend is to perform a pubovaginal
sling procedure. Patients with both urethral hypermobility and ISD are also
best treated by a pubovaginal sling operation.
¡@
- Anterior vaginal repair
¡@
- Anterior repair is most commonly used for correction of cystocele in
combination with urethral hypermobility. It can be combined with Kelly
plication of the urethra when, in addition to a cystocele, the patient is
experiencing stress incontinence.
¡@
- The purpose of the anterior repair is to reduce the cystocele and
reinforce the pubocervical fascia support of the bladder and urethra. In a
Kelly plication, the surgeon increases the intraurethral pressure to a level
higher than the intravesical pressure in the resting and stress state, such
as with a Valsalva maneuver.
¡@
- The anterior vaginal repair utilizes several modifications of the
original Kelly plication. All techniques include dissection of the anterior
vaginal wall from the underlying bladder base/bladder neck and simple
plication of the pubocervical fascia.
¡@
- The success of these operations as a group is somewhat lower than
retropubic or transvaginal needle suspensions. However, some specific
techniques achieve excellent success on objective follow-up.
¡@
- Based on retrospective chart reviews of 11 studies incorporating 957
patients, AHCPR reported an overall cure rate of 65% (range 31%-91%) and a
cure or improvement rate of 74% (range 31%-98%). Contrary to retrospective
chart reviews, recent outcomes data report that anterior vaginal repair does
not provide lasting cure as was previously thought. Based on Cochrane
review, anterior vaginal repair was less effective than retropubic
suspension based on patient-reported cure rates in eight trials both in the
short-term (failure rate within first year after anterior repair 82/279, 29%
vs 50/346, 14%) and long-term (after first year, 132/322, 41% vs 68/395,
17%). Currently, anterior vaginal repair is not recommended as a primary
treatment for correction of female stress urinary incontinence of any type.
¡@
- This procedure can be used in conjunction with vaginal hysterectomy or
repair of a cystocele. Anterior vaginal repair alone is not recommended for
correction of urethral hypermobility.
¡@
- Pubovaginal sling
¡@
- Sling procedures create a hammock-like bolstering of the urethra. A
supporting strip of material is placed under the bladder neck and secured to
the abdominal wall or a pelvic bone with permanent suture.
¡@
- In contrast to bladder neck suspensions, the sling provides a good
distribution of force to the entire undersurface of the urethra and is not
dependent on strength of periurethral tissues. All urethral slings have a
band of material placed directly beneath the urethra to prevent bladder neck
herniation.
¡@
- Unlike transvaginal bladder neck suspensions that have a failure rate of
47% after 2 years, pubovaginal sling procedures have a more durable
long-term cure rate of 83% after more than 4 years. (See
below).
Operations for intrinsic sphincter deficiency
Procedures for managing ISD include sling procedures, periurethral bulking
injections, and placement of an artificial urinary sphincter.
Sling procedures are recommended for women who have ISD alone or ISD with
coexisting hypermobility. Periurethral bulking injections are recommended as
first-line treatment for women with ISD who do not have coexisting hypermobility.
Artificial sphincter is recommended for ISD patients who are unable to perform
intermittent catheterization and have severe SUI that is unresponsive to other
surgical treatments.
¡@
- Pubovaginal sling
¡@
- The various sling procedures all involve placing a sling, made of either
autologous, synthetic, or cadaver material under the urethrovesical junction
and anchoring it to retropubic or abdominal structures or both. Sling
operations are often performed in women with complicated incontinence, many
of whom have failed previous attempts at surgical correction.
¡@
- Pubovaginal slings may be constructed from in-situ vaginal wall tissue,
fascia lata, or from the rectus fascia. The most common pubovaginal sling in
use today is constructed from the rectus fascia. Fascial pubovaginal slings
produce success rates of 89% cure and 92% cure or improved. According to
AHCPR, data from synthetic slings indicate that 78% were cured, and 88% were
cured or improved.
¡@
- The total complication rate given for the fascial sling series was
higher than that for the synthetic sling series. However, the synthetic
sling caused more severe complications directly attributable to local
effects of the sling material, such as erosion, nonhealing of the vaginal
wall, abscess, and vesicovaginal fistula.
¡@
- Characteristics of the synthetic material that appear to decrease
infectious/erosive complications include using a short patch graft,
mesh-like architecture, and antibacterial properties.
¡@
- Periurethral bulking agents
¡@
- Periurethral bulking injections involve the injection of materials such
as polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), collagen, or autologous fat under
cystoscopic guidance into or around the incompetent urethra. The result is
bulking of tissue. This helps the internal seal mechanism close off the flow
of urine. Injection of these agents into the periurethral tissue restores
the mucosal seal mechanism by effectively coapting the urethral mucosa at
rest.
¡@
- Historically, autologous fat was used, but it has been largely abandoned
due to early phagocytosis of adipocytes. PTFE also has been used in the
past; however, the risk of particle migration and granuloma formation has
restricted FDA approval.
¡@
- Another type of treatment, collagen injections, may also be an option
for patients with ISD. Increasing experience with collagen has established
its efficacy in the short-term, but as with Teflon injection, long-term
results beyond 5 years are not available.
¡@
- Injection of collagen is technically easier compared to that of PTFE.
Urinary tract infection and transient urethral irritation are the most
common side effects after periurethral collagen injection.
¡@
- According to the AHCPR, combined data from 15 studies of 528 women
indicate that after follow-up for up to 2 years, 49% of patients were cured
(range 8-100%), and 67% were either cured or improved. Complications
included urgency, UTI, and urinary retention.
¡@
- Artificial urinary sphincter
¡@
- The only surgical technique for incontinence that attempts to mimic the
active mechanism of natural continence is the artificial urinary sphincter.
The artificial urinary sphincter has been used for women with intrinsic
sphincter deficiency.
¡@
- According to the AHCPR, combined data from 8 studies of 192 women with
ISD treated with artificial sphincter placement reveals that 77% were dry,
and 80% were cured or improved.
¡@
- Complications included fluid leak, loose cuff, erosion or atrophy of the
cuff site, tubing kink, and infection.
¡@
- The artificial urinary sphincter does not have a significant role in
female stress urinary incontinence because of availability of other types of
surgery such as periurethral injection with bulking agents, or pubovaginal
sling. However, the artificial urinary sphincter is still an option if other
surgical modalities have failed.
Preoperative details:
- All patients should be informed of potential complications of
anti-incontinence surgery during the informed consent process. Complications
common to any anti-incontinence surgery include urethral obstruction and de
novo or worsening obstructive voiding symptoms.
¡@
- Patients with pre-existing urge incontinence should be treated with
anticholinergic therapy preoperatively.
¡@
- Patients undergoing sling surgery should be counseled on the possibility
of performing self-catheterization in the event urinary retention occurs
post-operatively. For patients receiving synthetic slings, possibility of
urethral or vaginal erosion should be discussed.
¡@
- Patients receiving artificial urinary sphincter should be informed of
potential mechanical malfunction that may require revisionary surgery.
¡@
- Eligible candidates for periurethral collagen injection should be skin
tested for possible allergic reaction 28 days before the scheduled injection
therapy.
¡@
- Pre-operatively, all patients should be cleared of any pre-existing
urinary tract infections. Intravenous broad-spectrum antibiotics are given on
the morning of surgery, ideally 1 hour before starting the operation.
Compressive pneumatic devices are placed on the lower extremities prior to
induction of anesthesia to prevent deep venous thrombosis.
Intraoperative details:
- Marshall-Marchetti-Krantz urethropexy
¡@
- All patients are given intravenous ampicillin and gentamicin
preoperatively. For patients with penicillin allergy, vancomycin is used.
The patient is placed in a modified lithotomy position or in a supine
position with the lower extremities in a frog-leg position.
¡@
- Abdomen and genitalia are prepared and draped in sterile fashion. A
Foley catheter is placed.
¡@
- Transverse suprapubic incision is made. Anterior rectus fascia is
incised.
¡@
- The bladder and the bladder neck are identified. The bladder neck is
identified by palpation of the Foley balloon. Placement of a hand in the
vagina facilitates the identification of the bladder neck.
¡@
- The prevesical fat is dissected off the bladder and the bladder neck.
Two or three non-absorbable suspension sutures, such as No. 1 Prolene, are
placed lateral to the bladder neck. The ends of the suspension sutures are
affixed to the periosteum of the pubic symphysis and then tied securely.
¡@
- The bladder neck is suspended by the sutures anchored to the
undersurface of the pubic bone. The suspension sutures prevent the bladder
neck's descent during periods of physical activity, but it does not "pull
up" the bladder neck high behind the pubic symphysis. Care should be taken
not to tie the bladder neck against the pubic symphysis. Overzealous pulling
up of the bladder neck will cause iatrogenic urethral obstruction.
¡@
- Burch urethropexy
¡@
- Broad-spectrum intravenous antibiotics are administered as described
above. The patient is placed in a modified lithotomy position or in a supine
position with the lower extremities in a frog-leg position.
¡@
- Abdomen and genitalia are prepared and draped in sterile fashion. A
Foley catheter is placed.
¡@
- Transverse suprapubic incision is made. Anterior rectus fascia is
incised.
¡@
- The bladder and the bladder neck are identified. The bladder neck is
identified by palpation of the Foley balloon. Placement of a hand in the
vagina will facilitate identification of the bladder neck.
¡@
- The prevesical fat is dissected off the bladder and the bladder neck.
Two or three non-absorbable suspension sutures, such as No. 1 Prolene, are
placed lateral to the bladder neck. The ends of the suspension sutures are
affixed to the Cooper's ligament and then tied securely.
¡@
- The bladder neck is suspended by the sutures anchored to the Cooper's
ligament. The suspension sutures prevent the bladder neck's descent during
periods of physical activity, but they do not "pull up" the bladder neck
high behind the pubic symphysis.
¡@
- Overzealous pulling up of the bladder neck will cause iatrogenic
urethral obstruction. There should be enough space behind the suspension
suture and the Cooper's ligament to readily admit 2 fingers.
¡@
- This new position allows even disposition of external pressures on all
surfaces of the bladder and the proximal urethra.
¡@
- Transvaginal urethropexy
¡@
- Administer broad-spectrum intravenous antibiotics. The patient is placed
in the lithotomy position. The vagina, perineum, and suprapubic area are
prepared and sterilely draped. A Foley catheter and self-retaining vaginal
retractor is placed.
¡@
- The bladder neck is identified. An inverted "U" incision is made over
the vaginal mucosa at the level of the bladder neck.
¡@
- The anterior vaginal wall is dissected off the periurethral and
pubocervical fascia toward the inferior ramus of the pubic bone. The
urethropelvic ligament is punctured through with Metzenbaum scissors,
creating a small space to facilitate the passage of suspension sutures.
¡@
- Three helical bites of the urethropelvic ligament, the pubocervical
fascia, and the vaginal wall excluding the epithelium are obtained using No.
1 Prolene suspension suture.
¡@
- The suspending sutures are transferred to the suprapubic incision using
a double-prong ligature carrier under digital guidance. The suspension
sutures are tied ipsilaterally and over the abdominal wall loosely. The
suspension sutures support the bladder neck in proper position and prevent
its descent during periods of physical activity. The vaginal and suprapubic
incisions are closed.
¡@
- One ampule of indigo carmine is given intravenously. Cystoscopy is
performed to exclude any suture intrusion into the urinary bladder or the
urethra. Clear efflux of blue urine from both ureteral orifices indicates
ureters have not been injured.
¡@
- Povidone-iodine soaked vaginal packing is placed. A urethral catheter is
inserted. Some surgeons may also place a percutaneous suprapubic tube as
well as a urethral catheter.
¡@
- Anterior repair and Kelly plication
¡@
- Broad-spectrum intravenous antibiotics are administered. The patient is
placed in lithotomy position. Vaginal and perineal area are prepared and
draped in sterile fashion. A Foley catheter is placed. Normal saline is
injected into the vaginal mucosa to facilitate hydrodissection. An inverted
"U" or midline vaginal incision is made.
¡@
- Anterior vaginal wall is dissected off the pubocervical fascia.
Pubocervical fascia is plicated at the midline with absorbable sutures in an
interrupted fashion.
¡@
- For Kelly plication, the periurethral fascia is plicated to increase the
intraurethral pressures. Redundant anterior vaginal wall is trimmed.
Anterior vaginal wall is closed.
¡@
- Rectus fascia pubovaginal sling
¡@
- All patients are given intravenous antibiotics preoperatively. The
patient is placed in the lithotomy position. A combined abdominal-vaginal
approach is used for the operation. A full 5-minute, povidone-iodine vaginal
and abdominal surgical scrub is performed. The vagina, perineum, and abdomen
are prepared and sterilely draped.
¡@
- A transverse incision is made over the suprapubic area. The incision is
carried down to the rectus fascia. Scarpa fascia overlying the rectus fascia
is dissected off. A 2 x 13 cm rectus fascia is harvested. The rectus fascia
is stored in antibiotic saline solution until ready for use.
¡@
- The abdominal fascia is closed using non-absorbable sutures. An
antibiotic soaked gauze is placed into the abdominal incision.
¡@
- A self-retaining vaginal retractor and a 16 Fr. Foley catheter is
placed. The bladder neck is identified by visual inspection of the anterior
vaginal wall and digital palpation of the Foley catheter.
¡@
- A single vertical midline incision or inverted "U" incision is made at
the level of the bladder neck. The anterior vaginal wall is dissected off
the pubocervical fascia. The urethropelvic ligament is punctured through to
create a small opening to allow passage of suspension sutures.
¡@
- The rectus pubovaginal sling is constructed at the back table with No. 1
Prolene suspension sutures. The pubovaginal sling is brought to the
operating table. The sling is centered at the bladder neck and affixed at 6
points with 4.0 Vicryl sutures. The suspension sutures are transferred
suprapubically.
¡@
- The vaginal wound is irrigated with bacitracin solution. The vaginal
incision is closed with 2.0 Vicryl suture in a continuous locking fashion.
¡@
- The suspension sutures are tied ipsilaterally and then across the
midline loosely. At the author's institution, the weight-adjusted spacing
nomogram is used to tie the suspension sutures.
¡@
- The subcutaneous tissues are approximated and the skin is closed with
running subcuticular suture. For obese patients who are at risk for seroma
formation, we place a small closed suction drain in the suprapubic area
prior to skin closure.
¡@
- One ampule of indigo carmine is given intravenously. Cystoscopy is
performed to exclude any suture intrusion into the urinary bladder or the
urethra. Clear efflux of blue urine from both ureteral orifices indicates
ureters have not been injured.
¡@
- Povidone-iodine soaked vaginal packing is inserted. Foley catheter
and/or suprapubic tube is placed.
¡@
- Fascia lata pubovaginal sling
¡@
- All patients are given intravenous antibiotics preoperatively. A
combined thigh-abdominal-vaginal approach is used for the operation. The
patient is placed in supine position with the inner leg stretched out and
the outer leg in a slightly bent position. All pressure points are
adequately padded to prevent pressure necrosis.
¡@
- The outer thigh is prepared with povidone-iodine solution and sterilely
draped. A skin incision is made on the outer thigh. A 2 x 13 cm fascia lata
is harvested. A special fascial stripper may be used for the harvest.
¡@
- A small Penrose drain is placed and the thigh incision is closed. A
compressive dressing is applied.
¡@
- The patient is re-positioned in a lithotomy position. A full 5-minute
povidone-iodine vaginal and abdominal surgical scrub is performed. The
vagina, perineum, and abdomen are prepared and sterilely draped.
¡@
- A transverse suprapubic incision is made. Incision is carried down to
the rectus fascia. Scarpa's fascia is dissected off the rectus fascia.
Antibiotic-soaked gauze is placed into the wound.
¡@
- A 16 Fr. Foley catheter and self-retaining vaginal retractor is placed.
The bladder neck is identified. A vertical midline incision or an inverted
"U" incision is made at the level of the bladder neck.
¡@
- The anterior vaginal wall is dissected off the pubocervical fascia. The
urethropelvic ligament is punctured through to create a small opening to
allow passage of suspension sutures.
¡@
- The fascia lata sling is constructed at the back table with No. 1
Prolene suspension sutures. The pubovaginal sling is brought to the
operating table. The sling is centered at the bladder neck and affixed at 6
points with 4.0 Vicryl sutures. The suspension sutures are transferred
suprapubically.
¡@
- The suspension sutures are tied ipsilaterally and then across the
midline loosely. Alternatively, the ends of the sling may be sewn to the
rectus fascia. At the author's institution, the weight-adjusted spacing
nomogram is used to tie the suspension sutures.
¡@
- The subcutaneous tissues are approximated and the skin is closed with
running subcuticular suture. For obese patients who are at risk of seroma
formation, we place a small closed suction drain in the suprapubic area
prior to skin closure.
¡@
- One ampule of indigo carmine is given intravenously. Cystoscopy is
performed to exclude any suture intrusion into the urinary bladder or the
urethra. Clear efflux of blue urine from both ureteral orifices indicates
ureters have not been injured.
¡@
- The vaginal wound is irrigated with bacitracin solution. The vaginal
incision is closed with 2.0 Vicryl suture in a continuous locking fashion.
Povidone-iodine soaked vaginal packing is inserted. Foley catheter and/or
suprapubic tube is placed.
¡@
- Tension-free vaginal tape
¡@
Postoperative details:
- Retropubic urethropexy
¡@
- Intravenous antibiotics are given for 48 hours, followed by an oral
cephalosporin. On the morning after surgery, the urethral catheter and
intravenous lines are discontinued.
¡@
- Patients are discharged on the second or third day after surgery. They
may perform normal physical activities after 4-6 weeks.
¡@
- Transvaginal urethropexy
¡@
- Intravenous antibiotics are given for 24 hours, followed by an oral
cephalosporin. The Foley catheter, vaginal packing, and intravenous lines
are discontinued on the morning after surgery.
¡@
- Patients are discharged on the first or second day after surgery. They
may perform light physical activities immediately. Sexual intercourse is
avoided for 6-8 weeks.
¡@
- If suprapubic tube has been placed, it is capped and the patient starts
to check the residual urine every 4 hours or as required. The suprapubic
catheter is removed as soon as the residual urine is less than 60 ml.
¡@
- Pubovaginal sling
¡@
- Intravenous antibiotics are given for 24 hours, followed by oral
antibiotics for several days. The Foley catheter and the vaginal packing are
removed on the morning following operation.
¡@
- The suprapubic catheter is plugged and the patient unplugs it every 4
hours to measure postvoid residuals. When the postvoid residuals become
minimal, the suprapubic tube is removed. If the patient still experiences
retention after 3 weeks, the suprapubic tube is removed and the patient is
taught self-intermittent catheterization.
¡@
- Periurethral bulking injections: Oral antibiotics are given for several
days. If stress urinary incontinence recurs or persists, repeat injection or
pubovaginal sling may be necessary.
¡@
- Artificial urinary sphincter: Intravenous antibiotics are given for 24
hours and oral cephalosporins are continued for several days. The sphincter is
left deactivated for 6 weeks. The device is activated, and the patient is
instructed on its use after 6 weeks of healing.
|
COMPLICATIONS |
¡@ |
Serious complications from operations that
correct stress incontinence occur very infrequently. Complications common to
bladder neck suspensions and pubovaginal slings include the following: urinary
retention, de novo or worsening obstructive voiding symptoms, urinary tract
infection, suture abscess, wound infection, retropubic bleeding, vaginal
granuloma, vesicocutaneous fistula, de novo pelvic prolapse, bladder
perforation, prolonged suprapubic pain, and ilioinguinal nerve entrapment.
The current incidence of urethral obstruction ranges from 5-10% for
anti-incontinence operations. Urinary retention is temporary in most cases, but
it may last a month or more. While the condition lasts, clean intermittent
catheterization should be performed. Less serious complications, such as wound
infection, occur more frequently but are easily treated with antibiotics. The
likelihood of needing a blood transfusion is less than 5% for all procedures.
- Retropubic bladder neck suspension
¡@
- Abdominal wound infection, urinary retention, de novo urge incontinence,
and dyspareunia occur in the 3-15% range.
- Up to 12% of patients experience postoperative enterocele and rectocele
occurrence after Burch urethropexy.
- ¡@
- Transvaginal bladder neck suspension
¡@
- Complications include urinary retention and de novo obstructive
symptoms. Retropubic bleeding may result in pelvic hematoma. De novo urge
incontinence and de novo pelvic prolapse may also occur. If bladder
perforation occurs, it is repaired transvaginally.
- Excessive tension of the suspending sutures or entrapment of
subcutaneous tissue over the rectus fascia may lead to prolonged suprapubic
pain. Lateral placement of suspension sutures may cause ilioinguinal nerve
entrapment.
¡@
- Percutaneous vesica urethropexy: Osteomyelitis and osteitis pubis are two
well-known complications of percutaneous bladder neck suspension using bone
anchors. Patients with infected pubic symphysis experience suprapubic pain and
difficulty with ambulation. They often walk with a waddling gait.
¡@
- Anterior vaginal repair and Kelly plication: Complications include
urethral obstruction and urethral infection.
- Rectus fascia pubovaginal sling
¡@
- Complications of sling surgery are similar to those of transvaginal
bladder neck suspensions; however, the risk of urethral obstruction is
higher. Chronic urinary retention, requiring self-intermittent
catheterization for a lifetime, is uncommon but may occur following surgery.
¡@
- The incidence of urethral obstruction after sling surgery is 2-10% and
the incidence of obstructive voiding symptoms range 5-25% in the literature.
De novo detrusor instability requiring anticholinergic therapy is found in
15-20% of the cases.
- Potential intraoperative complications include injury to the urethra,
bladder, or ureters during the dissection and during transfer of the
suspension sutures.
¡@
- Fascia lata pubovaginal sling
¡@
- As with any sling surgery, patients with fascia lata sling surgery may
have difficulty with volitional voiding postoperatively. In some, detrusor
instability may result in urge incontinence.
¡@
- Potential complications of sling surgery may include erosion of the
urethra, prolonged or permanent urinary retention, injury to the bladder or
ureters, and detrusor instability. Leg pain is a complication unique to
fascia lata sling operation.
¡@
- Synthetic pubovaginal sling: Synthetic slings may be constructed from
Gore-tex, antibacterial Gore-tex mesh, Prolene mesh, or Silastic.
Complications unique to synthetic slings include urethral erosion, nonhealing
of the vaginal wall, abscess, and vesicovaginal fistula. Antibacterial
properties, mesh-type architecture, and short patch grafts will decrease
infectious and erosive complications.
¡@
- While TVT is a synthetic sling, it is placed over the mid-urethra,
rather than the bladder neck. In addition, it is not fixed or tied anywhere
along its length. The mechanism of action of TVT is to create a "kink" in
the urethra when the patient performs a Vasalva maneuver. During a Valsalva
maneuver, TVT prevents the posterior wall of the urethra from moving
distally and opening up the bladder neck as the bladder neck descends. In
other words, the TVT remains fixed and then compresses the posterior wall of
the urethra to prevent a leak. When the patient relaxes, there is little or
no compression of the urethra. However, if the patient strains to void, she
will find it difficult or impossible to void at all, since this mimics a
Valsalva maneuver.
¡@
- Based on this "kinking" mechanism, the ideal patient for TVT is an
incontinent woman with urethral hypermobility. Despite it's name,
Tension-free Vaginal Tape is not tension-free unless the surgeon makes it as
such intraoperatively as previously described.
¡@
- Vaginal wall sling: Potential complications include retropubic bleeding,
bladder perforation, and ureteral obstruction. The reported incidence of
urinary retention is less than 5% with this procedure. Vaginal shortening has
not been reported to be a problem to date. However, cyst formation with
burying the island of vaginal epithelium is a potential complication.
- ¡@
- Periurethral collagen injection
¡@
- Urinary tract infection and irritative voiding symptoms are the most
common side effects after periurethral collagen injection. Symptoms of
urinary frequency and urgency are self-limited.
¡@
- Permanent urinary retention has not been reported. Urinary retention
responds well with temporary catheterization. Acute urinary retention after
collagen should not be treated by indwelling Foley catheter, or it can
"mold" the collagen and defeat the success of the operation.
¡@
- Rather, intermittent catheterization is preferred. If an indwelling
catheter is required in unusual situations, a suprapubic catheter can be
placed percutaneously to protect the collagen implant.
¡@
- Artificial urinary sphincter
¡@
- Complications of artificial urinary sphincter include urethral injury
during surgery, tissue atrophy, and delayed urethral erosion.
¡@
- Mechanical problems include fluid leak from the system, tubing kink, and
obstruction from particulate matters.
¡@
- Infectious complications include suprapubic or perineal cellulitis and
periprosthetic abscesses. Infection may lead to erosion and necessitate
repeat surgery to remove a portion or even all of the device.
|
FUTURE AND CONTROVERSIES
|
¡@ |
The management of long-term urinary
retention after a sling surgery remains controversial. Postoperative urinary
retention may be treated with indwelling catheter, intermittent catheterization,
cutting of suspension sutures, incision of the sling itself, or complete
urethrolysis with or without repeat sling procedure.
Acute urinary retention is initially treated with indwelling urethral
catheter or self-intermittent catheterization. If a suprapubic tube had been
placed intraoperatively, SPT is left indwelling. In majority of cases, patients
are able to void spontaneously within three weeks and catheterizations are
discontinued.
If urinary retention persists at three weeks, pressure-flow study must be
performed to document a well-functioning detrusor and rule out urethral
obstruction. If the patient has atonic detrusor, she needs long-term
catheterization, intermittent or otherwise.
If the patient has a normal detrusor function, an alternative to intermittent
catheterization is to takedown one or both suspension sutures. This procedure is
performed by going through the original suprapubic incision and cutting
ipsilateral suspension sutures. This may be done under local or general
anesthesia. If the patient still remains obstructed after cutting the suspension
sutures, one should perform urethrolysis.
Timing of urethrolysis is controversial. If urinary retention occurs after a
rectus fascial sling, urethrolysis is recommended after three months of urethral
obstruction. If urethral obstruction results after a synthetic sling,
urethrolysis should be performed earlier than three months.
Regardless of the sling material used, this author recommends early
intervention (usually at three weeks) rather than delayed since the patient's
quality of life is impaired during the duration of retention.
Formal urethrolysis of autologous sling involves complete dissection
circumferentially around the bladder neck and proximal urethra. Conversely,
urethrolysis of a synthetic sling may require only an incision of one or both
arms of the sling rather than complete dissection of an autologous sling.
After urethrolysis of rectus fascial sling, one may choose to place another
autologous sling to prevent recurrent stress incontinence. If urethral injury is
encountered, the urethral injury is repaired primarily and either Martius fat
pad (fat pad from labia majora), omentum, or posterior peritoneum may be used to
reinforce the closure. Whether to proceed with another sling at the time of
urethrolysis should be tailored to each individual patient. At our institution,
we have not resorted to placing a second sling as all our patients have remained
continent after formal urethrolysis.
Despite these potential complications, it is important to realize that
pubovaginal sling is an excellent operation for all types of female stress
urinary incontinence. Many types of sling operations abound. Sling surgeries may
involve autologous tissue, synthetic biomaterials, and cadaver allografts. A
particular type of operation chosen depends on the patient’s preference and the
surgeon’s expertise. When performed properly, the long-term cure rate of sling
surgery should approach 90% with minimal complications.
The future of anti-continence surgical therapy is bright and promising. With
advances in biomechanical engineering coupled with clinical and basic science
research, our understanding of the incontinence disease process and the
development of new surgical options are increasing rapidly. With current
evolution of stem cell research and genetic engineering, more minimally invasive
and technologically advanced surgical procedures will be forthcoming in the near
future.
|
BIBLIOGRAPHY |
¡@ |
- Athanassopoulos A, Melekos MD, Speakman M: Stamey endoscopic vesical neck
suspension in female urinary stress incontinence: results and changes in
various urodynamic parameters. Int Urol Nephrol 1994; 26(3): 293-9[Medline].
- Bidmead J, Cardozo L: The management of tape exposure after inserting
tension-free vaginal tape. BJU Int 2001 Mar; 87(4): 414.
- Burgio KL, Matthews KA, Engel BT: Prevalence, incidence and correlates of
urinary incontinence in healthy, middle-aged women. J Urol 1991 Nov; 146(5):
1255-9[Medline].
- Carlin BI, Klutke JJ, Klutke CG: The tension-free vaginal tape procedure
for the treatment of stress incontinence in the female patient. Urology 2000
Dec 4; 56(6 Suppl 1): 28-31[Medline].
- Chaikin DC, Rosenthal J, Blaivas JG: Pubovaginal fascial sling for all
types of stress urinary incontinence: long-term analysis. J Urol 1998 Oct;
160(4): 1312-6[Medline].
- Chin YK, Stanton SL: A follow up of silastic sling for genuine stress
incontinence. Br J Obstet Gynaecol 1995 Feb; 102(2): 143-7[Medline].
- Choe JM: Surgical Options. In: Freedom Regained: Female Urinary
Incontinence Can Be Overcome. Columbus, OH: Anadem Publishing; 1999: 173-202.
- Choe JM, Staskin DR: Gore-Tex patch sling: 7 years later. Urology 1999
Oct; 54(4): 641-6[Medline].
- Choe JM, Ogan K, Battino BS: Antimicrobial mesh versus vaginal wall sling:
a comparative outcomes analysis. J Urol 2000 Jun; 163(6): 1829-34[Medline].
- Choe JM, Ogan K, Bennett S: Antibacterial mesh sling: a prospective
outcome analysis. Urology 2000 Apr; 55(4): 515-20[Medline].
- Das S: Comparative outcome analysis of laparoscopic colposuspension,
abdominal colposuspension and vaginal needle suspension for female urinary
incontinence. J Urol 1998 Aug; 160(2): 368-71[Medline].
- Foldspang A, Mommsen S: Adult female urinary incontinence and childhood
bedwetting [see comments]. J Urol 1994 Jul; 152(1): 85-8[Medline].
- Glazener CM, Cooper K: Anterior vaginal repair for urinary incontinence in
women (Cochrane Review). Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2001; 1: CD001755[Medline].
- Haab F, Trockman BA, Zimmern PE: Results of pubovaginal sling for the
treatment of intrinsic sphincteric deficiency determined by questionnaire
analysis [see comments]. J Urol 1997 Nov; 158(5): 1738-41[Medline].
- Korman HJ, Sirls LT, Kirkemo AK: Success rate of modified Pereyra bladder
neck suspension determined by outcomes analysis. J Urol 1994 Nov; 152(5 Pt 1):
1453-7[Medline].
- Langer R, Ron-el R, Newman M: Detrusor instability following
colposuspension for urinary stress incontinence. Br J Obstet Gynaecol 1988
Jun; 95(6): 607-10[Medline].
- Leach GE, Dmochowski RR, Appell RA: Female Stress Urinary Incontinence
Clinical Guidelines Panel summary report on surgical management of female
stress urinary incontinence. The American Urological Association [see
comments]. ALYSIS 1997 Sep; 158(3 Pt 1): 875-80[Medline].
- McLennan MT, Melick CF, Bent AE: Clinical and urodynamic predictors of
delayed voiding after fascia lata suburethral sling. Obstet Gynecol 1998 Oct;
92(4 Pt 1): 608-12[Medline].
- Morgan JE, Heritz DM, Stewart FE: The polypropylene pubovaginal sling for
the treatment of recurrent stress urinary incontinence. J Urol 1995 Sep;
154(3): 1013-4; discussion 1015-6[Medline].
- Romanzi LJ, Blaivas JG: Protracted urinary retention necessitating
urethrolysis following tension-free vaginal tape surgery. J Urol 2000 Dec;
164(6): 2022-3[Medline].
- Staskin DR, Choe JM, Breslin DS: The Gore-tex sling procedure for female
sphincteric incontinence: indications, technique, and results. World J Urol
1997; 15(5): 295-9[Medline].
- Wolin LH: Stress incontinence in young, healthy nulliparous female
subjects. J Urol 1969 Apr; 101(4): 545-9[Medline].