RobertNiles.com
About Robert
Reporting Help
Finding Data on the Internet
Questions for Candidates
Stats Lessons
Mean
Median
Percent
Per capita
Standard Deviation
Margin of Error
Data Analysis
Sample Sizes
Stats Tests
Help Board
Bookstore


A Mathematician Reads the Newspaper

Read about reporters who blew it when trying to write about stats. A mathematician leads you through the tricks, citing contemporary examples.
More information
-->

Home > Statistics Every Writer Should Know > The Stats Board > Discusssion

Experimental Design
Message posted by Edwin on December 1, 1999 at 12:00 AM (ET)

Hi,

I really need help. I am doing research on mathematics
education. I intend to compare the performance of 12 groups of students.
There is one control group and 11 treatment groups.
All the students will be tested and taught individually.
Should I just lump them all into one experiment or
do I break them up into several experiments? What are the disadvantages
of lumping them all into one experiment
with regard to the statistical analysis
done. I hope to run a one-way ANOVA. The groups are as follows:


Conventional Teaching (Control)
Conventional Teaching+Use of calculator
Conventional teaching+Use of Heuristics
Conventional Teaching+Use of calculators+Use of heuristics
Worked Example
Worked Example+Use of Calculators
Worked example+Use of heuristics
Worked Example+Use of calculator+use of heuristics
Pure Worked Example
Pure Worked Example+Use of Calculators
Pure Worked example+Use of heuristics
Pure Worked Example+Use of calculator+use of heuristics

Would really appreciate any help I can get.

Please help?

Ed.


READERS RESPOND:
(In chronological order. Most recent at the bottom.)

Re: Experimental Design
Message posted by Bill on December 2, 1999 at 12:00 AM (ET)

Remember the KISS (kept it simple stupid) approach. From my experience, many studies collapse under their own weight. Unless you have a tremendous amount of resources, this design looks as if it may be a candidate for such a collapse. You may find it helpful to focus your study, i.e., conduct several smaller experiments.



Your $5 contribution helps cover part the $500 annual cost of keeping this site online.

Niles Online Sites:RobertNiles.comTheme Park InsiderViolinist.com

RobertNiles.com™, the site, content and services 咀opyright 1996-2002, Robert Niles.
All rights reserved. Questions? Comments? Read my Privacy Policy, or E-mail me!